Choosing the right handgun for concealed carry is a deeply personal decision, and the Glock 23, in both its Gen 4 and Gen 5 iterations, remains a popular contender. This in-depth comparison will analyze the key differences between the Glock 23 Gen 4 and Gen 5, helping you decide which model best suits your needs and preferences.
Key Differences: Gen 4 vs. Gen 5
While both generations share the same basic design and caliber (.40 S&W), several subtle yet significant improvements distinguish the Gen 5 from its predecessor.
1. Trigger:
- Gen 4: Features a slightly heavier, more textured trigger with an ambidextrous paddle-style magazine release.
- Gen 5: Boasts a refined, smoother trigger pull with a reduced trigger weight and a slightly more pronounced reset. The ambidextrous magazine release is replaced by a reversible mag release. This allows for a more customizable experience.
Which is better? The Gen 5 trigger is generally considered superior for its smoother, lighter pull, leading to improved accuracy and a more pleasant shooting experience. However, personal preference plays a crucial role here.
2. Slide:**
- Gen 4: Features noticeably aggressive texturing on the front and rear of the slide, enhancing grip.
- Gen 5: Maintains the aggressive texturing but introduces a nDLC (nitride) finish. This finish enhances corrosion resistance and reduces friction for smoother cycling. The Gen 5 also features a fully ambidextrous slide stop lever.
Which is better? The Gen 5's nDLC finish offers superior durability and corrosion resistance, making it a more practical choice for various conditions.
3. Recoil Spring Assembly:**
- Gen 4: Uses a dual recoil spring assembly.
- Gen 5: Employs a single, more robust recoil spring assembly that contributes to reduced felt recoil and improved reliability.
Which is better? The Gen 5's single recoil spring assembly is generally viewed as a refinement, leading to smoother operation.
4. Magazine Release:**
- Gen 4: Uses an ambidextrous paddle magazine release.
- Gen 5: Features a reversible ambidextrous magazine release. This allows shooters to choose either a left or right-side placement.
Which is better? The Gen 5's reversible system offers more customization, catering to both right and left-handed shooters. It is also considered more robust and less prone to accidental activation.
5. Other Notable Differences:**
- The Gen 5 Glock 23 features a slightly improved front serration design for easier slide manipulation.
- While not a significant difference, some users find the Gen 5's slightly lighter weight an advantage.
Which Generation Should You Choose?
The choice between the Glock 23 Gen 4 and Gen 5 largely boils down to personal preference and priorities.
-
Choose the Gen 4 if: You prefer a slightly heavier trigger pull and a more pronounced paddle-style magazine release. The price may also be lower on a used Gen 4.
-
Choose the Gen 5 if: You prioritize a smoother, lighter trigger pull, superior corrosion resistance (nDLC finish), a more robust recoil spring assembly, and a reversible magazine release.
Ultimately, handling both models is recommended before making a final decision. Consider renting or borrowing each to assess the ergonomics and trigger pull for yourself. Remember, the best firearm is the one that feels best in your hand and allows you to shoot accurately and comfortably.
