The Smith & Wesson M&P15 platform, a popular choice for AR-15 enthusiasts, offers a versatile base for customization. While many opt for modern, flat-top receivers, the retro appeal of the carry handle upper receiver continues to attract shooters seeking a classic aesthetic and a unique shooting experience. This guide delves into the features, benefits, and considerations of choosing an M&P15 with a carry handle.
Understanding the Carry Handle Upper Receiver
The carry handle upper receiver is a defining feature of older AR-15 designs. It integrates the rear sight directly into the upper receiver, eliminating the need for a separate rear sight and providing a built-in carrying handle. This design, while less versatile than modern flat-tops, offers several advantages:
Benefits of a Carry Handle M&P15:
- Classic Aesthetic: The carry handle instantly evokes a nostalgic feel, reminiscent of classic military rifles. This aesthetic appeal is a key draw for many collectors and enthusiasts.
- Built-in Sight: The integrated rear sight provides a reliable sighting solution, simplifying setup and eliminating the need for a separate rear sight.
- Enhanced Durability (potentially): Some argue the integral design of the carry handle contributes to a potentially more robust upper receiver, though this is subjective and depends on manufacturing quality.
- Simplified Optics (potentially): While not as common, some users appreciate the simplified optic setup; with a carry handle, the only optic needed is a front sight and a properly zeroed rear iron sight in the carry handle itself.
Drawbacks of a Carry Handle M&P15:
- Limited Versatility: The fixed carry handle limits the options for mounting optics like red dot sights or scopes. While some adapters exist, they can be cumbersome and may affect zeroing.
- Higher Sightline: The carry handle's higher sightline can make it less ideal for close-quarters combat scenarios or for those accustomed to lower sightlines offered by picatinny rail-mounted optics.
- Weight: The carry handle adds extra weight to the rifle compared to a flat-top upper receiver. While this might be negligible for some, it's a consideration for others.
Choosing the Right M&P15 Carry Handle Setup
Before purchasing an M&P15 with a carry handle, carefully consider your intended use. If you prioritize optic versatility or low-profile sighting, a flat-top receiver might be a better choice. However, if the retro look and integrated sights appeal to you, the carry handle offers a unique and satisfying shooting experience.
Considerations for Purchase:
- Intended Use: Will this be primarily a range gun, a home-defense weapon, or something else? Your intended purpose significantly influences the optimal choice.
- Budget: Carry handle M&P15s can vary in price depending on the manufacturer and included features. Set a budget before you start shopping.
- Manufacturer: Smith & Wesson produces high-quality firearms, but it's always wise to research different manufacturers and read reviews before making a purchase.
- Accessories: Consider any additional accessories you may need, such as different front sights or carrying cases.
Conclusion: A Niche But Valuable Option
The M&P15 carry handle upper receiver represents a niche within the AR-15 market, catering to those who appreciate its classic aesthetic and integrated sight system. While it lacks the versatility of flat-top receivers, it offers a unique shooting experience and a distinct visual appeal. Careful consideration of the benefits and drawbacks will help you determine if an M&P15 with a carry handle is the right choice for your needs. Remember always to prioritize safety and handle firearms responsibly.
